
Nadine with her Dad
My dad dug the hole I live in.
He didn’t dig it on his own, and the new housing subdivision of Stonefields where I live (about five kilometres from Auckland’s CBD) is more of a crater than a hole. But, every morning when I walk these streets, I can’t help but think of my dad.
He wasn’t part of my life, growing up. My parents separated before I was two years old and my earliest memories are shaped by his absence. I remember sitting by the window some days, looking out into the world, wondering where he could be.
It turns out that much of the time he was right here, driving a digger at the base of Mt Wellington on Lunn Avenue. This was the old Winstone’s quarry from 1936 until it was closed down in 2001. The rock and stone that was excavated from here was used to build Auckland from the ground up. Motorways. Footpaths. Concrete pipes and foundations for our earliest skyscrapers. I like to imagine there are stones from the Lunn Ave quarry supporting the base of the Auckland Harbour Bridge. And under the Southern Motorway, the central artery of this sprawling city.
Stones for concrete, bucket by bucket. As each fresh load was carted away, Maungarei, the watchful mountain, has kept track.
Before Winstone Aggregates broke the ground, Ngāti Huarere, Te Waiohua, Ngāti Maru and Ngāti Maniapoto all made their home here at different times. On the eastern slopes there were extensive gardens, fertile terraces like shelves that are still visible on the landscape today.
Significant pā belonging to Ngāti Paoa (Mokoia and Mauinaina) were here too, fortifications built to fend off invasions by Ngāti Whatua and Ngāpuhi. I’m certainly no authority on the history, and I’m sure there’s plenty of different kōrero depending on who you ask. But when I look up towards Maungarei, the great shadow of her imposing figure assures me she remembers it all.
My dad did his bit. Digging, loading, crushing, driving. He’s Peter Hura, Ngāti Hine, one of 11 children from Waiomio, near Kawakawa. He came to Auckland in the 1960s, met his English rose in Papakura, and they married. He was 19 and she was 16. By the time the decade was up, they’d had three children and were in way over their heads.
I don’t know much of the detail, but I do know that when my mother left my dad, clothes and blankets jammed to the roof of the old Morris Minor, she was getting out of a bad situation. I don’t blame her for leaving. She was thinking only of her children and what would be best for us.
And so I grew up, a half-caste kid of divorced parents, with a Māori father who I never saw. I didn’t carry that knowledge as a stigma, so much as a secret I had to protect. My survival instincts were finely honed — they had to be in 1980s New Zealand.
Luckily, I’d been born with pale skin and light-coloured eyes. I drifted under the radar, laughing at the racist punchlines of “English-Irish-Māori-man” jokes so as not to give myself away.
My mother tried to make things easier by changing our name as soon as she could. She was unshackling me, she thought, from the kind of prejudice she’d suffered when using her married name. Renting houses, applying for loans, getting doctor’s appointments — all of it so much more difficult if you had a Māori surname. She was being practical, not cynical.
My brothers had a harder time. The colour of their skin left no room for doubt. I remember a girl once jeering at me in the playground. “That’s your brother isn’t it?” she said, pointing to the lone dark figure kicking a ball in the quad. The other kids laughed and snorted, and I was torn between wanting to claim my brother and wanting desperately to belong.
Why couldn’t I be Māori and still belong?
Well, because I grew up believing that to be Māori was to be dumb. Lazy, naughty, snot-nosed and barefoot. Māori kids were slow to read but quick to run. They slept in their clothes. Used coat hangers for car aerials. Pissed everything they earned up against the wall.
It’s always the stereotypes that hurt the most.
It wasn’t until I went to university that I began to question the subconscious messages I’d absorbed all my life. It began with an innocuously-worded essay question about something called “the political economy of labour migration”. This is just a convoluted, academic way of talking about the government policies that influence the flow and movement of people for economic reasons.
Little did I know that, in my quest to understand this concept, I was taking the first step back towards the father I’d lost. I learned, for example, that, when he first pitched up in Papakura in 1966, he was part of a wave of young men lured to the city by the promise of steady work and good fortune.
The post-war New Zealand economy was booming. With guaranteed market access to the UK for our agricultural products, the government needed to industrialise urgently, and who better to build the required factories and roads, buildings, houses, motorways, than the swathes of idle, rural Māori just a few hours away?
But, separated from their communal lands for the first time, Māori didn’t always fare well in the city. Blue-collar work doesn’t exactly offer many opportunities for promotion or advancement. Unskilled labour, they call it, although I’m fairly certain it takes skill to excavate rocks out of the hillside.
The isolation from whānau and communal life brought problems. Alcohol. Poverty. Social dislocation. The more I read and researched the topic, the more personal it became. I began to realise that the “numbers” referred to in my books were not numbers at all, but men and women with names. Men — absent fathers — with children.
When I finally completed that assignment and handed it in, I didn’t necessarily forgive my father for his absence. But, for the first time, I understood it. Sometimes there’s no one to blame for our hardships — we’re all just products of our time.
In the same breath, I began the long road to forgiving myself. It’s one thing to deny your own identity, but it’s another to deny that of the people you love. When the girl at school asked me if that boy in the quad was my brother, I actually don’t remember what I said. I only remember hesitating. And I carried that guilt for years.
But that’s the reality of the country where I grew up. That’s the unremembered, unacknowledged New Zealand of the 1980s. A country where a child like me grew up thinking that I was lucky to be white. A country that let me believe that colour mattered at all.
You can always fight overt racism, but it’s the racism we absorb subconsciously that’s the most damaging. It’s the messages our children internalise through popular culture, language, social media. Even as we congratulate ourselves on how progressive we are as a bicultural nation, the harmful stereotypes still persist today.
Like the idea that Māori are lazy.
The irony of this hits me every morning when I walk around this new suburb built in a gigantic hole that took 60 years to excavate. At its deepest point, the jagged stone face is about 30 metres vertical. Walk around here for five minutes and you will see the scars on the landscape. Exposed earth, like the inside of a stomach. Raw. Rugged.
The diggers are still here, in fact. New rows of houses are going in all the time. As I take my 6am walk, I wave to the workers, brown faces all of them, and I want to yell: “Hey! My dad dug this hole!” Because I’m proud, I guess. Of who I am and where I come from. I no longer have any secrets. I finally know where my dad was all those years of my childhood when he wasn’t with me. He was down here, calloused hand to the lever, scraping, loading, driving.
A few years ago, I reconnected with him. He’d made the first move not long after I turned 17. But I was arrogant. I thought: “I’ve come this far without you. I don’t need you now.”
It wasn’t until I did the total immersion reo course that I began to really engage with forgiveness and moving on. And a big part of that, weirdly, was just being able to korero Māori with him. I don’t really know how to explain that — but the language seemed to bring us closer together
He’s 68 now and still working 10 hours a day, 6 days a week. He should have retired three years ago, but it goes against everything he knows to be idle. He ticked over 33 years with the same company last year — their longest-serving employee. Barely a sick day to his name. Hardly someone you’d call lazy.
The first time my dad came to visit me in Stonefields, he stood on the pavement and looked a bit bewildered. He pointed out different landmarks. The roundabout near the cafe where they found the kōiwi, the bones, that closed the quarry for days. The spot near the cliffs where they filmed, apparently, Xena: Warrior Princess.
“Auē! There was plenty of watercress down there where your house is, too,” he said, licking his lips at the memory.
Each morning, as I walk around this suburb I now call home, I know that the mountain watches. She watches my kids, too, as they ride their bikes to school, play tag in the playground, run home in the rain. From terraced gardens to film sets to the diggers that hauled rocks to make way for the house that I now live in. The presence of this mountain reminds me that she remembers it all — and that mine is but one more chapter in a story that goes on and on.
© e-tangata, 2015
Thank you for reading E-Tangata. If you like our focus on Māori and Pasifika stories, interviews, and commentary, we need your help. Our content takes skill, long hours and hard work. But we're a small team and not-for-profit, so we need the support of our readers to keep going.
If you support our kaupapa and want to see us continue, please consider making a one-off donation or contributing $5 or $10 a month.
Thank you for sharing Nadine.
Thank you for sharing Nadine. A beautifully written article. Such a sadly familiar story …. Let’s hope our society moves forward. Mary-Anne
Hi Nadine, Thanks for an
Hi Nadine, Thanks for an interesting read. I would like to know if you knew about your father working at Stonefields before you moved there or was it a coincidence?
Hi Judy,
Hi Judy,
Sorry I didn’t reply sooner, I have only just read your comment now. It was entirely coincidental – the first time my Dad came to visit me here he told me that he used to work here when it was the Lunn Ave Quarry. My morning walks were never the same after that! It immediately changed the way I viewed Stonefields and I reflected a lot on the strange cycles that our lives move in. It definitely seemed like a tohu (sign) of some kind.
Thanks for reading.
Your dad must be very proud
Your dad must be very proud of you. He is a lovely man
Ka nui te mihi, thank you for
Ka nui te mihi, thank you for sharing your memories, I’m sure that the memories you are able to build with you’re father now will be precious. Our men/dad’s of the 50s and on, hard working, misunderstood and sometimes the only relief they had, was the pub and their mate’s. Our Mum once commented that if she had known how hard it was going to be for us, 8mof us, she wouldn’t have had so many. Yes it was hard, still is some days however we rise above it. Kia kaha koe.
Thank you Nadine for a
Thank you Nadine for a beautiful Saturday read. Hi Tink! It was a lovely walk down memory lane. I remember your Dad’s brother. The reason why there is a four after my name is because there were two Tom Nathan’s at the time. I lived in Mangere Bridge & Tom lived in Papkura, because of this I was asked what number I liked, so I chose 4 & Tom 2 was created. Funniest moment, Ratu Tibbles we would get him inebriated (drunk) his wife was a beautiful lady we feared, when we would take him home, we’d leave him leaning in the doorway, ring the bell & run as fast as our trotters would carry us back to the car that was still running. Some of the gentlemen I remember fondly are Darkie Wairepo, Jimmy Whittaker, James Cougar & the yard foreman Barney Clews to just to name a few. From my family to all, may God Bless you, may the festive season be all that you hope, may the New Year be prosperous. Merry Christmas xxx Tamati Nathan 4
Tena koe Nadine
Tena koe Nadine
I know your father through our current employment with the Fletcher Construction Project. I am 1 of the several cartage contractors that was transporting the aggregate material from Winstones Hunua quarry to the Waterview worksite. I have also been involved in cartage jobs for Fletchers around the Panmure area including Stonefields. There has been some amazing discoveries associated with local iwi history in that area and with regards to maori sensitivity and respect, Fletcher Construction have done a great job so obviously a very good working partnership is at hand.
Tama tu, tama ora, tama moe, tama mate
This whakatauki has been somewhat the driving force behind me for many many years, and I am sure many others who understand what it means would agree that it is essentially important to remember. Not just Maori but for all individuals. Kia ora
Kiaora after reading your
Kiaora after reading your article I came to realise that this was a reflection of your life and the experiences you had growing up. From my own personal life my mother was from Te Arawa and my father was from the Cook Islands. I am very proud of both cultures and come from a huge whanau that has many other positive examples. My family have amongst them lawyers, teachers and other professionals including whanau who are accountants and a sister who works for a lawyers firm as well myself who works in the health profession. It is so derogatory to look down on all Maori and Pacific and yes i have exprienced it but my parents were the best examples of hard working honest people. We had seven children and my Dad on one wage back in the 1960s was able to work at his job on the power lines and brought a house and looked after us well. We were well provided for and had a happy life and that was also due to the good example of my Koro and Nanny who had 15 children. So there are great Maori and Pacific families like mine who are all working and are not dole bludgers but rather some of us have been working since we were 15 and are now in our 50s and have mokos ourselves. So we will teach the same morals and work ethic to our tamariki..and when I come across that ignorant predjudiced attitude of all Maori are lazy…then I smile and show them and tell them how my lineage of employed whanau has been passed on from my whanau who have passed away. So just remeber there are so many good examples of whanau who never get a mention. …ka kite
Tena koe Nadine a very
Tena koe Nadine a very surreal life experience.I am a former Winstone aggregates lunn ave worker having had the pleasure of working not only with your dad but also 2 of his brothers Ted & Hira so happy to hear your dad is still enjoying his work its hard to keep us old school lads down.A life time of stories could be told if that quarry spoke which is what you have done here amongst your lifes story such a touching life story it is & thanks for sharing it.You would be not alone growing in the 80s thinking you were white but i no as you get wiser forgiveness comes easy. please tell dad i said hello i reside in Brisbae now but always find time to zap around the old hole i may see on your walk 1 day you never know I’ll be sharing the link for other former workmates to read they will buzz at this. Meri Kerihimete me nga mihi o te tau hou
Tēnā koe Blue, thank you so
Tēnā koe Blue, thank you so much for stopping by and adding your comments. I’m just buzzing with all the kōrero coming out about the Quarry, so many lives have intersected with this place. My Dad is enjoying reading the comments as well, recognising a few names and no doubt remembering a story or two. Give me a wave next time you’re in town, kia pai tō Kerihimete hoki, Nadine
Beautifully written honesty.
Beautifully written honesty. Thankyou!
Kia ora Pierre.
Kia ora Pierre.
Kia ora Te Aroha
He mihi nui ki a koe, Nadine.
This is beautiful and so perceptive. For what it is worth, my great great grandmother was Moetu Te Hura aka Moetu Taui.
I totally support what has just been said. You write beautifully.
You write beautifully, Nadine
You write beautifully, Nadine and I think every New Zealander should read this piece.
Thank you Dale!!
Thank you Dale!!
Kia ora toyou Nadine. Coming
Kia ora toyou Nadine. Coming to Wellington in 1965 i met my first Maori. He told me his name was Bill McGregor. I nearly laughed out loud. He was a really nice guy, lots of fun and musical on guitar. So I never got to believe that Maori were lazy a.nd now some 50years later my appreciation of your k aupapa has grown to a point where I wish I could connect in a serious way. Thank you so much for your expose, I found it moving in unexpected ways. Kia tau ki te rangimarie. (Hope that is close to what I hope for, a peaceful heart. )
A beautiful but sad story
A beautiful but sad story Nadine. As a pakeha growing up in Auckland I remember some of the racism. My own generous caring dad saying “Maori liked working outside” in response to my question about why so many drove bulldozers. Then a friend who married a Maori women not taking her when looking for a place to rent because they would get turned awat. A comment from a woman in an ecumenical group trying to reach out to Maori families moving into Auckland – “they chop down their front stairs to use for firewood”. I now have 3 mokpuna who are being educated in Te reo and know they will experience racism because I am pakeha and know what we do and say and think.
Keep writing Nadine. You have
Keep writing Nadine. You have a gift.
Kia kaha.
Thank you! nga mihi mo tenei
Thank you! nga mihi mo tenei tautoko.
Good for you! You took the
Good for you! You took the path of healing and love! Very courageous! Keep up the good work.
Kia ora Nadine. I’m a Pakeha
Kia ora Nadine. I’m a Pakeha living in Oz, raised in Invercargill in the 1970s. I also grew up with those awful attitudes, never understood them – one of my favourite men was a wonderful Maori man called Pat Hokianga who was chief mechanic at our family garage. Their whanau gatherings had a beauty and warmth that our self-contained little family unit lacked. It took a while as an adult to really really work those ingrained racist attitudes out of my system, out of my guts really – the rules of society can be insidious and so deadly. What I saw of the few Maori in the deep south in those days was in stark contrast to the stereotypes that were bandied around. Thanks for your courage in writing, for sharing something deep and important to us all, Maori and pakeha.
Thank you! Yes, the negative
Thank you! Yes, the negative stereotypes are the worst, particularly because for children they can be internalised as self-fulfilling prophecies. Thanks for your comments.
Hi Nadine – I really loved
Hi Nadine – I really loved reading this – so much of what you said rang true for me. Being fair skinned made me feel (many times) that I was not entitled to acknowledge what was rightfully, emotionally and spiritually mine. Being adopted – my mother preferred to let people think I was of Italian or Spanish descent – she knew the prejudices of our town – I don’t blame her in any way. I remember finding out who my father and my whanau was and feeling so incredibly proud. Proud to belong – to be “part of”. Proud to be what I knew all along. The reaction of others was both positive and negative. One person told me “I’d get over it ” – as if being Maori was something you choose – if you have the skin colour that allows it!. It has taken many years to be where I am at today. My whanau is a great source of comfort – my lighthouse in the dark. They are beautiful, and accepting.
I know who I am.
My sister Charmeyne posted this to her FB.
Wow, so many parallels in our
Wow, so many parallels in our stories, and many others who can also relate. That pride in our identity is integral to who we are. Nga mihi nui.
Kiaora Nadine your story is
Kiaora Nadine your story is so touching as i can relate to some of it. My dad Butler Morunga his mates Dick Tate, Harry Te Namu also worked at winstones quarry (they drove fodens) along with my husband Robert Walker who was a shot firer, they shared a week about with their vehicles from Papakura to Lunn Ave 6 days a week. Lots of beautiful people worked here lots of lovely memories
In researching this article I
In researching this article I obtained a book from Winstones that they published a few years ago and it includes several pages on the Lunn Ave Quarry. Pictures of the machines and the crusher etc, one B&W image of a pretty impressive explosion taking place. My Dad was blown away to see the pictures. I wonder if it’s in the library and you could look it up….
This is a great and
This is a great and insightful article. When i first lived in Auckland in the 1950s and 60s I didn’t know any Maori or Pacific Islander who was unemployed. Like most country and Island people they lived a subsistence life which meant work, work, work. Incidentally I have a grand daughter and whanau living in Stone Fields.
My kids and your moko
My kids and your moko probably go to school together – it’s a wonderful school and culturally very rich.
lovely story of her life, her
lovely story of her life, her mums courage to do what she thought best for her kids. What a burden to carry all those years. I’ve got so much respect for her. I didn’t know this happened in nz,I am of Maori descent and proud of it but so often was referred to as a pakeha, you don’t have to be dark to be Maori I used to say, most Maoris are of mixed denomination. I left nz in1974 for Australia and been here ever since arohanui…….
Nadine – another thoughtful,
Nadine – another thoughtful, beautiful, well written piece. Well done. I remember you talking of some of these issues when we were in Samoa. I’m so proud of you! X
Thanks Heath xx
Thanks Heath xx
Kia ora Nadine,
Kia ora Nadine,
What a beautiful story with healing intertwined in its threads. My sisters and I (Wendy and Katie) sold Xmas trees for 20 years outside Winstones Quarry gates, College Rd entrance, until it closed.
In those years all the Winstones workmen were exceptionally kind and thoughtful. In fact, I’m sure they kept a good watchful fatherly eye on us at the gate!! Yes, at times the Quarry Men enjoyed a beer or two after a hard days work! Lol Whilst names fade in to history, the kindness of all those Men towards us young girls will never fade in our minds. People would try to steal our site.. And the Men would stay loyal and keep us there!
Big LOVE to your Peter, our Murray, Dave?, Scotsman Etc and the little strong Maori foreman who’s name forsakes me!
These Men were a big part of our lives each Yuletide!!
Nadine… Thank you for your sharing! Xxx Love Danielle and the Xmas tree girls (retired from duty) lol xxx
What a great story, thanks
What a great story, thanks for sharing! Twenty years is a long time too. I noticed there are christmas tree-sellers just at the top of Lunn Ave, I’ll give them a wave next time I go past. It’s amazing to remember how our landscape has changed and to remember those who have gone before us. I wonder how many other simple stories out there just waiting to be told. Nga mihi maioha,
great story… i passed that
great story… i passed that quarry many of times before during and after living in Point England with my young Family. I left Nz and all the new housing was starting to pop up in that area. Even the new of block of Eatery spots was nice too as me and wifey would frequent a Thai retaurant there lol. East Auckland is changing….. and its a positive look.
Kia ora Nadine, like your dad
Kia ora Nadine, like your dad, I worked the quarry filling it in with tunnel tailing from down towards Penrose, not a lot of people are aware, there’s a tunnel that runs under the southern motorway from Penrose to the wharf in the city. It’s big enough to take a truck but has just the one lane, anyway, why I’m writing is to inform you of a good friend who, last Saturday, 5th of Dec, turned 73. He worked for winstones for many many years and as he became too old for the big rigs and heavy machines, they made him the company courier, driving the winstones courier car. His name is Tom Nathan. Lives here in Australia , Perth.
Thank you for taking the time
Thank you for taking the time to share this story, the social history is fascinating – and, no, I did not know that there is a tunnel from Penrose to the city. Imagine that! Please give my regards to Tom, this is a great big hole he helped to dig over here 🙂
Thanks again for another
Thanks again for another piece that connects.
Passionately written Nadine
Passionately written Nadine and this resonates with me personally …nga mihi
Love your word Nadine
Love your word Nadine beautifully heart felt in your delivery. It’s interesting although not surprising that when we becomemore informed about our roots we connect with who we are & find peace in that moving forward. If I never had that opportunity I wonder how life would have been otherwise & cringe lol. Thank you from this Maori(Ngati porou) living in Perth
Thank you for your kind words
Thank you for your kind words – and to all the encouraging comments and feedback above and below as well, nga mihi nui ki a koutou katoa!
Tena koe Nadine
Tena koe Nadine
In short you make me proud to be Maori. I love your writings and have taken to saving them for my personal reference. never stop writing.
Nga mihi
Wow, that comment just makes
Wow, that comment just makes my day. Thank you so much.
Tena Koe e Nadine, kia ora mo
Tena Koe e Nadine, kia ora mo to purakau. Nga mihi ki a koe.
Tēnā koe Nadine. This sounds
Tēnā koe Nadine. This sounds like my life and brought me to tears. Ka nui te mihi ki a koe me ōu hokinga mahara.
Wow!!! And Wow!!! The one
Wow!!! And Wow!!! The one thing that really summed it up for me was “we are all a product of our time” that resonates really strongly with me. Your story is known by many, but only you can own the details of your story. How many of us can relate to this journey is beyond the horizon of another day. Awesome and inspirational.
Thank you!
Thank you!
Thanks for sharing such a
Thanks for sharing such a well written reflection. Nga mihi.
So beautifully written, the
So beautifully written, the maori tag that many of us experienced yet few have been able to articulate, e mihi ana koe e te tuahine.
Tena koe te tuahine. Ko
Tena koe te tuahine. Ko Hineamaru te tupuna. Ko Waiomio te kainga, ko Mohinui te marae, ko Ngati Hine te iwi.
Tēnā koe taku whanaunga!
Tēnā koe taku whanaunga!
Kia ora Nadine m, your long
Kia ora Nadine m, your long walk back will be supported. There is much that will waken your heart about who you are & who you come from.
I knew your grandparents John and Kaa Hura. Your grandmother was the kuia who recorded all the poka at the wahitapu. Not only that, she knew whanau memories. Recently, my whanau started to prepare ourselves for our unveilings of loved ones. Suddenly we missed your grandmother who came to every whanau about their unveiling plans. Now we have to rely on our own records, death notices, unrecorded memories. One of our brothers is buried under another relative whose whanau probably didnt check with her If she were here, she would step in and broach difficult issues.
If you want to, please contact me about our unveilings next year about April.
Nga mihi kia koe me o korero. Na Te-Aroha Henare
Thank you Te Aroha, that
Thank you Te Aroha, that would be amazing! Ka imera au ki a koe.
Kia ora Nadine, another
Kia ora Nadine, another excellent kōrero… Be great to share this with the Kura… Ngā mihi nunui ki a koutou ko tō whānau, ko tō pāpā rātou ko ngā kai mahi katoa, ahakoa te mamae e pā mai nei e pā ana ki tō tātou maunga rā me ōna koiwi kai raro rā e… Moe mai rā e te hunga rā… Mauri ora ki a tātou ngā kanohi ora e noho mai nei… !
Ngā mihi Jacqs, and I need to
Ngā mihi Jacqs, and I need to thank you too because I had this article in mind for a long time, but I was lacking the kōrero around the history of the maunga, which you kindly sent through to us a few weeks ago. It’s amazing to know these stories and to feel the wairua of the people who have lived and worked here before us. Tēnā koe mo tou tautoko ki au.