I started US election week in San Francisco, hanging with a bunch of Māori and native Hawaiians and Alaskans, mulling over indigenous values and leadership. By the weekend, I was back home, speaking at the Te Aute College prizegiving. The hall shook as students erupted into a spontaneous mass haka to induct one of their own as head prefect for 2017. Seeing him stand there, head bowed, strong yet humble — then watching him join the haka with equal pride and passion — well, it made my heart sing.
Because, in between those two invigorating celebrations of native leadership, a nasty, narcissistic reality TV star with dodgy business credentials, a short attention span and obnoxious attitude — a self-confessed sex offender and serial liar —was voted Top Dog in the World. Decisively.
Democracy had not just spoken, it had screeched.
While Bernie Sanders initially had “nothing polite to say” about the Democrats or the president-elect, commentators and journalists are still picking over the carcass of one of the nastiest elections in American history.
Trump beckoned to the poor and the privileged, the racist and the God-fearing. His off-the-chart shameless rhetoric drew in anyone who felt hard done by and angry. Yes. Even women. Latinos. People on a good whack. Republican diehards. There were black folk wearing the red caps at his victory event.
Trump tapped into their real and imagined grievances. He captured all that pent-up resentment, frustration and anger and then, like a charlatan hosting a séance, channeled it into convenient scapegoats. He spoke in tongues and people heard what they wanted to hear. Even as he lied through his teeth, even if he was lacking in ideology, policy, expertise, detail and logic, it wasn’t what he said that was important. It’s how he made his followers feel. And he made them feel like he was one of them smashing up against “the establishment”.
Bernie Sanders also railed against the status quo and neo-liberalism. “A Future to Believe In,” he said. Bernie excited and mobilised a movement by connecting with young people in particular — and that’s no mean feat. But we never got to see the Sanders movement go up against the Trump one.
Now the self-proclaimed “greatest democracy in the world” is descending into the Disunited States of America. As a dangerous cabal gathers around the authoritarian Trump, protests are erupting. Reports are coming in of racially-motivated attacks and abuse. Trump has let the genie out of the bottle and it’s an ugly little bastard. But it was always there. Trump just gave people permission to be upfront about it.
We can stab it with our steely knives, but we just can’t kill the beast.
Hotel California keeps running through my brain.
Many of us outside America are simply shaking our heads. “Ana — kaitoa. Karma. Chickens have come home to roost.” Look at their record — the consequences of US foreign policy, the expansion of America’s military presence, the history of slavery and ongoing brutality against Afro-Americans. And in San Francisco, I heard native Hawaiians continually refer to the invasion of their islands, and how the US bought Alaska from the Russians in 1867, before it became the 49th state in 1959.
As supporters piled into Standing Rock in opposition to the state of North Dakota and oil corporations, mainstream media ignored the biggest protest in their midst. I kept waiting for a discussion panel on CNN that would include a First Nations commentator, or a poll that would take the pulse of America’s native people. We heard about blacks, Latinos, women and youth — but not from or about tangata whenua. Democracy doesn’t work for those who don’t have the numbers. In the lead-up to election night, First Nations people were invisible. Make America Great Again would’ve had a whole different meaning for them.
As we move towards our own election, can we afford to get too smug? Is there a possibility that New Zealand could produce our own Trump? I mean, there’s creepy stuff going on here too.
Iwi/Kiwi. Māori privilege. We are all one. One law for all.
We have political leaders here who aren’t averse to scapegoating Māori to score points. Winston Peters springs to mind. Don Brash. Read the comments section under any sane article about racism or Pākehā privilege and you understand how disconnected some New Zealanders are from facts. There’s a Māori4Trump Facebook page, for God’s sake, and plenty who, despite Trump’s dangerous rhetoric, are adopting a “let’s wait and see” attitude.
In San Fran, I asked participants to identify those core values that define us as First Nations peoples, to explore what leadership traditionally looked like. Then I ran an exercise similar to one Moana Jackson led for a bunch of us in the ‘80s: “What would your country look like if your lot took over at midnight? How could you use those key values we just talked about to build new systems and processes that are inclusive, kind, and respectful, so the whole country remains functional in a global sense?”
I gave them 20 minutes.
When each group reported back, there was no mention of deportations or retribution or isolation or building walls. The new power structures began at community and island level, and spread out and upwards. The new world order envisaged by these young people was based on old school values: whanaungatanga, manaakitanga and kaitiakitanga. In other words, what’s good for Māori and other First Nations people is good for everyone.
These kids were actually talking about constitutional transformation. It’s big and important stuff that a relatively young country like ours can do. Heck, we’ve been talking about it for long enough.
Now I’m no politician or academic, but hanging out with these young folk in both the US and New Zealand was uplifting. It was a celebration of legacy and potential. I’m reminded of the visionaries in our whakapapa, the academics and activists in our midst — and the fresh, young, critical minds we can tap into in order to think and dream big.
I believe Māori are entering a very interesting time. We’re starting to critique our own people and institutions at grassroots and national level, which is a big thing. More and more Pākehā are doing the same thing.
It’s important we draw on our shared values and keep joining forces. New Zealanders do it so well in times of adversity. Last week, as Rūaumoko, Tangaroa and Tāwhirimātea rose defiantly from their slumber, Ngāi Tahu and local marae worked alongside emergency services, the defence forces and volunteers to help those affected by Monday’s earthquake. Manaakitanga is something New Zealanders are famous for.
The US election was a wake-up call. It taught me how important it is to support responsible and quality journalism, and to be wary of newsfeeds on social media. We have to prepare to deal to a Trump talkalike, because someone here will have been taking notes from the nasty dude (who didn’t even bother to have his wife standing next to him when he did his victory speech).
It’s time to whip our own passions and anger into a movement that’s transformative and visionary and values-based. One that has kindness and respect at its heart, and that political parties will be forced to respond to.
If we don’t stand for something, we’ll fall for anything. (Reverend Al Sharpton.)
Courage. Integrity. Authenticity. That’s what counts. Collaboration. Mobilisation. That’s what we need to do.
You can check out anytime you want, but you can never leave.
So it’s game on. Keep calm and fight on.
Thank you for reading E-Tangata. If you like our focus on Māori and Pasifika stories, interviews, and commentary, we need your help. Our content takes skill, long hours and hard work. But we're a small team and not-for-profit, so we need the support of our readers to keep going.
If you support our kaupapa and want to see us continue, please consider making a one-off donation or contributing $5 or $10 a month.
Thanks Moana for your
Thanks Moana for your perspective about the Trump phenomenon. I admit to becoming over time an admirer of Donald J Trump after being somewhat tentative at the beginning. I warmed to this man more when in my view mainstream media negative narrative and biased approach evidently backed Hillary Clinton and Donald Trumps quote’s we’re manufactured to suit their narrative. I couldn’t help but relate that to Maori experience of media marginalisation and the anger the we Maori endured of TV, print, and NZ talkback. We always love the underdog and Donald Trump was that for me all be it resourceful, wealthy. Feminists want a 1st Woman President – Hillary was the wrong one and in a presidential war she had bad strategy, integrity and results, and if she would have been successful TPPA and Wars would have continued. Indigenous minorities in the USA can only thrive on a strengthened middle class TRUMP has appealed to this constituency. Making connections to Nazi Germany rhetoric I believe is unfair towards Donald as Obama with his charm has made appalling and dispicable war mongering decisions which have caused immense misery in the inner city ghettos as well as the global impoverised and oppressed. But also i could connect Trump to the great “I have a dream” speech of MLK which uses the the same cues of emotive influence. Brexit, Trump is a trend of people reclaiming their power of tipping the pyramid. Thanks again much respect to you for sharing your perspective.
Great stuff.
Great stuff.
Your time in the US was well spent; you tapped into some marvelous insights.
Only one bone of contention:
> (Trump) was voted Top Dog in the World. Decisively.
Not so.
Trump got about 24 per cent of the vote, nearly 2 per cent less than HRC, or just under 3 million fewer votes.
75 per cent of the registered voters DID NOT vote for Trump.
Nearly half of the registered voters didn’t want to stand in line on a cold Tuesday after work to vote for a woman who is part of the establishment they despise.
Never mind that several million potential Democratic Party voters didn’t or couldn’t register to vote . . . but that’s another story.
Please keep up the good work.
rgds,
bw
Kia ora Moana, you’ve
Kia ora Moana, you’ve expressed pungently and poetically the dangers that Trump reflects and reveals. He can’t be given ‘time’ to show his intentions and become ‘normatised” as some commentators are suggesting. His narcissistic psychopathic intentions have always been clear, and are now being institutionalised through his appointments to offices.
Not sure if you’ve read George Lakoff, the neurolinguist’, analyses of Trump’s language – framing and metaphor and repetition – but they’re some of the most compelling explanations of why, as you identify, Trump’s appeal cuts across ‘borders’. And why his noxious ideologies could activate similar in NZ, and Australia where I now live.
Thank you for highlighting how to deal with him and strengthen people power in NZ.
Incisive analysis, Moana.
Incisive analysis, Moana. Thanks for stimulating thought through this piece, as well your contributions to our First Nations Futures Program. We’re hoping for an encore performance next year. E mālama.
I’m a bit late to your korero
I’m a bit late to your korero here, but gee Moana you are so talented at picking the spots of shaded light and giving it true clarity. I am a “lets see how it rolls in the US” person, but it has stimulated a resolve to get our own homes in order here. Clarity for our families,business, communities, runanga and post governance settlements. That we build and nurture the relationships that keep us as a successful bicultural nation hosting and giving manaaki to our global new NZers. We have to reinforce what we have to withstand the global disruptions, of which Trump is but one.
Excellent perspective. Most
Excellent perspective. Most uplifting.
Well written Moana. You
Well written Moana. You mention Hillary is streets ahead of Trump, I would disagree. Hes untested but so far his 3 top appointments are very worrying. Had you been a supporter of Hillary or even indifferent to her before Wikileaks, you could be forgiven but if after what has been revealed youre of similar mind – then its unforgivable. Under Hillarys tenure (and Obamas) 120Billion in arms sold to Saudi Arabia. Shes part of a most sinister group providing arms to terrorists in Syria and the Govt of Yemen. Civilans are targeted by this group. ISIS and ISIL are funded by the US indirectly through the Saudis, Israel. There was no choice as usual. This fascist country arrested Jill Stein the leader of the Green Party in 2012 for arriving at a presidential debate in the hope of being included given she was on the ballot.
Thanks for another great read
Thanks for another great read mete. Perhaps all the divisiveness, rioting and backstabbing by the Democrats is a sign of their frustrations at having Bernie Sanders, their overwhelmingly popular choice, to run against Trump, usurped by Clinton’s mega-millions and the Party hierarchy which she had in her pocket. Millions said if Bernie wasn’t elected as their Party candidate, that no way would they vote to elect Clinton to carry on her fourth decade of warmongering in the East and criminality, by any other name, in the corridors of government. Upsets of this nature in politics only occur when a candidate, despite spending ultra-millions on publicity, intense propaganda and parading of well-known public personalities, is abhorred by the voters. That’s why some States flipped their voting patterns, from Democrat to Republican by as much as 60% which is miraculous. Look at similar outcomes on election nights, even here, to see why huge turnarounds occur. Its the mum and dad voters, hardly the rubbish burning radicals or the disenfranchised, who use the democratic process to make their voices heard.
Thank you for your kind
Thank you for your kind comments. It makes up for the increasing numbers of Trump supporters popping into my Facebook feeds, Māori included, who overlook the fact that Trump won on the basis of his continued autocratic, populist and divisive screechings – and by channelling Hitler and Mussolini (whose phrases he used). I’m watching people as they say “better Trump than Hillary.” What’s happened to those values I talk about?! Am no fan of Hillary but she is streets ahead of this unstable dictator who has already banned Washington Post and New York Times from media gatherings (1st step for any dictator) and is holding private meetings with Heads of State (no advisors or media allowed). Watch as more and more people start to say Trumps ravings and behaviour are ‘normal.’
well written, Moana !!
well written, Moana !!
kia ora moana yes its really
kia ora moana yes its really inspiring to read what you have said and yes I do agree we do need to stand for something and take action instead of just standing on the sideline and letting people say and do what has happened with the American election
Thanks for your korero, a
Thanks for your korero, a scary thought that a NZ trump may emerge. It feels like there is an awakening amongst inDigenous
Peoples, Iaue I hope so. Think
What we all could do! Great the mahi you do Moana, thankyou.
Kia ora Moana, I agree with
Kia ora Moana, I agree with everything you say here. You cut to the most important things that we need more than ever – kindness and respect. I believe if we try to foster those values in all areas of our lives, we will truly make a difference and a better Aotearoa for everyone. It never hurts to be kind and show respect towards others. I just don’t understand what happened with the election in the USA…so sad for so many people.
This is such a powerful piece
This is such a powerful piece of writing and insight. We do need to stand for something and take action rather than be bystanders.
Bless you dear walking angel
Bless you dear walking angel of the living Moana xxx
I so enjoyed reading what you had to say in your post. Aroha mia e hoa and respect and much Aroha thank you xxx
Oh the wisdom… Lest we
Oh the wisdom… Lest we forget… when good people say nothing, evil prevails! Well put and let’s hear more of the same resounding throughout this country. Kia kaha Moana.
Well said and insightful
Well said and insightful Moana – thank you. It is more important than ever now to hold fast to values and stand up for what is right. As you are role-modelling.